Joe Auricchio

Courtesy Valkonien at TMBO. Original thread with more images.

Today, Kyle said to me:

So, you know that whole hd dvd key thing? Everyone and their grandmother knows it now, or knows where to find it. But I don’t think anyone knows what the heck to do with it.

Why did the HD-DVD key become such an issue?

Content providers: Takedown letters are not the way to stop piracy. Still less are they the way to squelch people with an agenda.

Bloggers, Diggers, etc: Copying and pasting a couple dozen bytes does not equate to taking to the streets in glorious revolution. The key’s been public for months. Those who needed it to do business (software developers and pirates) had it long ago.

Forgive me if I sound reactionary. I’m on the bloggers’ side on the whole. Certainly I’m no friend to the MPAA and RIAA. I just thought we’d been through all of this back in 2002 when DVD-Jon went to trial. It’s the same DMCA, same technology (video DRM), same fair use and anticircumvention issues. Of course, none of these issues actually came up in Johansen’s trial; they were just discussed to death on the net. I’m annoyed that this all came back a few days ago, but glad everybody shut up at the end of the day.

TMBO had a photo (sorry, no link) of a guy who tattooed the key to his chest. He’s going to feel really silly next year when nobody remembers or cares anymore, and even sillier in five when the next-next-gen formats arrive with the same folks backing them.

(I hope he feels silly already because back when we had the export restrictions fifteen years ago people did the same with strong crypto algorithms.)